As we begin to shift into the colder fall and winter months, you may be considering purchasing a new comforter. When thinking about which bedding to buy, you’ll likely come across different down comforters. How can you sort through the dozens, if not hundreds, options available? Our review of the six best down comforters and buyer’s guide can help guide you in the right direction.

Comparison Table

How We Chose Our Ratings

Many of our customers have been clamoring for our review of the best down comforters, which motivated us to come up with this list. We began by testing dozens of down comforters. We checked the blankets for things such as fill power, comfort, and warmth. We also considered factors like the thread count of the quilt and who the manufacturer was.

But, we did not stop there. We then looked up various online customer reviews for the top comforters that we had on our list. We did this to ensure that the products we tested were reviewed favorably by those who had used the product night in and night out. We removed two comforters on our list because there were customer concerns about how quickly the down lost its fill capacity.

Image by congerdesign via Pixabay

After browsing through thousands of online reviews, we came up with the list of the six best down comforters that you’ll find below. We believe that you cannot go wrong choosing one of these options. However, we also want to hear from you. If you have tried a comforter on the list, or see that we did not include your favorite down comforter, please leave a comment below.

We trust our readers and value our community, which is why we invite your thoughts and feedback. Together, we can work to construct the list of the six best down comforters. We look forward to you choosing one of the options on our list and providing your thoughts after you have used the quilt for at least a few nights.

Top Six Best Down Comforters

Below, you’ll find our recommendations for the best down comforters available today. The quilts you see below factor in things such as cost and the manufacturer. We believe that by choosing one of these comforters, you’ll be satisfied with a product that not only keeps you warm but is incredibly comfortable as well.

Three Geese Luxury White Goose Down Feather Comforter

This product is also affordable, with prices ranging from about $$ for a twin to a little less than $$ for a king.

Three Geese made this comforter with a blend of authentic goose down and an alternative filling. The bedding also comes with an anti-dust cotton cover. These two features work to cut down on the allergy risks for users. The quilt features a medium thickness, and it warm enough for customers to use throughout the year. Three Geese offers a 100 percent money back guarantee on this product.

Linenspa All-Season White Down Alternative Quilted Comforter

Of those who reviewed the product, more than 70 percent gave it a five-star rating. The product earned an Amazon’s Choice label for those searching for “down comforters.” The price ranges from $$ to $$ depending on which size you buy. Sizes range from Twin to Oversized King.

The comforter is available in multiple colors, including white, stone/charcoal, sand/mocha, and cloudy sky. Linenspa designed the bedding so that it was safe for both the washing machine and the dryer. The blanket also comes with eight anchor points for a duvet cover, as opposed to the traditional four that many other comforters have.

When browsing comments from other customers, one of the things that stood out the most was the fact that the comforter was incredibly lightweight. Customers noted that the comforter fluffed up after putting it in the dryer and that it was remarkably comfortable as a result. Some indicated that they felt this blanket was a cross between a comforter and a duvet because of how lightweight it was.

No products found.

No products found.

If you’re in search of authentic down comforters, you may want to consider this product from Rosecose. Of those who reviewed the product, 70 percent gave it a five-star rating. The comforter comes in three sizes, twin, queen, and king. The price ranges from $$$ to $$$.

Unlike some of the other options on our list, this quilt only comes in white. However, its thread count is 1200, and it features a fill power rating of 750, so customers know they are purchasing an incredibly comfortable product. Even though Rosecose makes this comforter with authentic down, it is still hypo-allergenic and allergy-free. The blanket weighs 50 ounces.

Customers noted that the product was vacuum-sealed when they received it, and they recommended leaving it to sit for a few days to allow the downtime to expand. Other customers said that they put the comforter in the dryer without any heat to encourage the down to expand. Customers also remarked that this comforter was one of the best they had ever had and that it was like sleeping on a cloud.

No products found.

No products found.

Another option you may want to consider is the Utopia product. If you’re shopping for a down comforter while on a budget, this could be a strong candidate for you. The price ranges from $$ to $$ depending on which size comforter you buy. 

Of those who reviewed the product, an astounding 90 percent gave it either a four or five-star rating. Customers remarked that the comforter was lightweight and felt “airy.” They also appreciated the fact that the quilt had a hypoallergenic barrier that helped cut down on potential allergy risks.

Egyptian Bedding Goose Down Comforter

Another comfortable option for those in search of an authentic down comforter. Of those who reviewed the product, 80 percent gave it a five-star rating. Egyptian Bedding produces the comforter in three different sizes: King, Queen, and Twin. The price of the comforter ranges from $$$ to about $$$.

The company states that this product provides medium warmth throughout the year. The blanket’s fill power is 750. Additionally, the company made the comforter with an Egyptian Cotton 1200 thread count, which they say not only prevents down from escaping but is also hypo-allergenic. This product comes with a full warranty and a money back guarantee.

When leaving online reviews, customers raved about how plush this comforter was. They noted that the quilt’s materials were of very high quality and that the comforter fluffed up within a day or two of removing it from its packaging, even though it was vacuum sealed. Customers also seemed to appreciate that the bedding was heavier, remarking that they trusted it to keep them warm during the winter.

No products found.

No products found.

For those who don’t mind using a synthetic comforter and are looking for something affordable, this product from AmazonBasics could be an excellent option. Of those who reviewed the product, 80 percent gave it either a four or five-star rating.

This comforter only comes in two sizes, Full/Queen and King. The former costs just under $$, while the latter costs a little more than $$. The comforter is lightweight since it contains synthetic down. Customers remarked that even though this comforter was lighter than others, it still managed to keep them warm. They also said that they would use it as a cheap alternative.

Buyer’s Guide

Photo by Roberto Nickson from Pexels

No matter if you’re buying your first down comforter or looking to replace the one you currently own, you’ll want to consider a few criteria when making your selection. By reviewing these factors, you’ll greater improve your chances of purchasing a product that will last for years. Below, you’ll find the factors we consider most important to consider when buying a new down comforter.

Types of Down

When choosing a down comforter, you’ll find that there are multiple material types from which you can choose. Manufacturers fill the inside of the quilt with down, which comes from the bird’s undercoat. It’s primarily known for the fact that it is soft, lightweight, and high-quality. There are no quills in a down comforter, unlike other blankets that use actual feathers.

One of the most popular types of down options is goose. When browsing goose down comforters, you may find that they use either gray or white down. The color should not have any impact on the quality of the blanket. However, the fact that the down is either gray or white is essential because it reduces the chance of the material showing through the white shell of the comforter.

Image by DieterRobbins via Pixabay

Another option you’ll have when selecting one of the best down comforters is duck. Duck is not as common as goose, but it remains a viable option. Duck down should be considered by those looking for a more affordable down comforter, as they are typically cheaper than goose down comforters. Duck down is excellent for keeping warm.

If you prefer not to have authentic down, you could also choose synthetic materials as well. Manufacturers design them so that they are just as comfortable as genuine down. These could also be an excellent option for those with allergies, as they may be hypoallergenic. Typically, the materials that go into a synthetic down comforter are:

• Polyester
• Cotton
• Wool

Fill Power

Another thing to consider when choosing a down comforter is the fill power of the down. The fill power indicates how much space one ounce of the down consumes. Lower-end comforters may not have the fill power listed on the label, but higher-end comforters should. The higher the fill power of the quilt, the fluffier it will be. It will also be much more insulating as well.

If you’re going to be using the down comforter in cold environments, you should consider a down comforter with a fill power of greater than 800. This is the highest possible fill power option available. Fill powers ranging from 600 to 799 are a bit lighter in weight but should still keep you warm. Fill options 400 – 599 are excellent all-season options, while a rating below 400 is best for summer months.

Design and Construction

You’ll also want to pay attention to the design and construction of the blanket. There are six or seven designs that manufacturers use when producing down comforters. The most often used is the baffle box, where strips of fabric are in both sides. Manufacturers then fill these square compartments with down. The chambers also allow the down to expand to its maximum capacity.

Image by Wokandapix via Pixabay

A similar design is the diamond quilt. Here, the fabric is sewn into both sides of the blanket but in a diamond pattern. This results in squares identical to the baffle box design, but much smaller. Because the shapes are smaller, there is less room for the down material to shift. Both the baffle box and diamond designs may come with a gusset, which is a wall of fabric sewn into the outer edge.

Other designs used in down comforters include the karo-step, the ring-stitch, the sewn-through box stitch, and the sewn-through channel stitch. Karo-step comforters come with cross stitching that prevents the fill from moving. Ring-stitches result in the top and bottom of the blanket being sewn together by small circles. Box and channel stitches are different patterns used when stitching.

Featured image by Jaymantri via Pexels.